Wednesday, 7 November 2012

Discussing Issues

           I have been finding that many students are more than willing to talk about “controversial” topics or topics that are highly relatable. Topics about conspiracies, about teenage stereotypes, marriage, and gender seem to transform a quiet class into a talkative group where many students are more than willing to voice their thoughts. There are also always quiet students in these situations as well. These silent students might be introverts or have their mind focused elsewhere; however we need to remember that they may be feeling isolated or uncomfortable with the topic.

Appleman explains in chapter eight that literary lenses can be a way to discuss issues more comfortably. This is seen in the example of Ayanna, the only student of color in her class, because here she expresses that she finds that the lenses used in her class make her feel less isolated. Literary lenses can be understood as a way to discuss issues more comfortable, such as issues of social power and gender (p. 118). I think that this is valuable because students want to talk about societies issues and seem to become engaged when controversial topics come up. Learning how to use literary lenses properly then can help us teach students to engage issues in a respectful intellectual way. It can also help us tie in current events with our literature which can further connect us to our bigger world. I believe that the potential lenses have for discussing issues is extremely valuable as a teacher candidate because I want to be able to discuss controversial issues with my students. It is during these teachable moments that we can get students to start thinking about inequalities and power.

1 comment:

  1. Hurrah! Well said, Sarah! I love the little hints at democratic action: "engaged [in] controversial topics" and "engage in issues in a respectful intellectual way." See you are political!

    You're so right about the students desire to go further, and I am seeing this too, the students do want to discuss these topics but I feel that they are not being given the opportunity to do so in the classes I observe. Perhaps, though, I am looking for the big lesson plan rather than the "teachable moments" that you speak of.

    Could changing the way we teach English be in these baby steps? Would switching from comprehension questions to lenses and deeper reading result in pandemonium amongst the students who have been following the status quo their entire student lives?

    ReplyDelete